Jon Stewart won Cable News Twitter yesterday with the announcement of his eventual retirement from helming The Daily Show. I expect that this will overflow into Wednesday’s conversation as well. Meanwhile, The Kelly File won best hour, followed by The Daily Show, Anderson Cooper 360, On The Record w/Greta Van Susteren, and Morning Joe:
click to enlarge
Raw data for the day: 2015-02-10-ShowStats.csv
Fox News was on top of Cable News Twitter in January, with more mentions than the other 4 networks. CNN came in second and, on some days, even topped Fox News. MSNBC was in third play, but at no time exceeded the mentions of Fox or CNN. HLN and Al Jazeera bumped along the bottom, with HLN occasionally showing a bit of life from time to time.
Charts after the jump:
The Kelly File won best hour in Cable News Twitter, while HBO’s Last Week Tonight (which has a repeat on Monday) won the best day overall. Last Week Tonight’s strength follows on its win for best hour on Sunday; as the show airs so late in the evening on Sunday follow-on conversation naturally spills into Monday.
Following Kelly for best hour was Hannity, 7am Morning Joe, On The Record w/Greta Van Susteren, and 6 am Morning Joe:
click to enlarge
Raw data for the day: 2015-02-09-ShowStats.csv
John Oliver is back and wins Cable News Twitter on Sunday. Oliver was followed by the two hours of Harris-Perry, the 9am hour of Kornacki, and, first time at the top, Al Jazeera’s 8pm news:
click to enlarge
Raw data: 2015-02-08-ShowStats.csv
Fox News’ Cashin’ In exploded on Twitter Saturday, with 7K mentions during the 11am hour and 41K mentions during the day. The 7K mentions is a dramatic jump for Cashin’ In, but, for me, the amazing result is the 41K mentions throughout the day: usually, Cashin’ In’s discussion quiets down fairly quickly after the show finishes, but not this Saturday.
Let me get the rest of Cable News Twitter out of the way before we dive into Cashin’ In’s results. Following Cashin’ In for best hour were Up w/Steve Kornacki, Judge Jeanine, and the each of the two hours of The Melissa Harris-Perry Show:
click to enlarge
I don’t usually include a graph showing the total mentions for the day, but in this case it’s worth sharing:
click to enlarge
Note that in second place is The Five w/Hosts, which includes mentions of Eric Bolling, the host of Cashin’ In. It is unclear what portion of The Five‘s mentions are really for Cashin’ In, but is safe to assume a very large percentage are. That’s part of the challenge of social media analytics — it’s nearly impossible to be 100% accurate in categorizing people’s messy tweets…
Eric Bolling, the host of Cashin’ In, launched a new hashtag for the show, #WakeUpAmerica, and it definitely woke up Twitter. There were over 31K mentions of that hashtag on Saturday. Not surprisingly, there were almost immediately some criticisms and questions about its success.
First came the question of whether the hashtag was already in widespread use and not related to Cashin’ In. So let’s look back a week at how often the hashtag was used. @EricBolling first announced his adoption of #WakeUpAmerica on Friday, 2/6:
click to enlarge
Clearly, #WakeUpAmerica was fairly dormant coming into the weekend, averaging under 400 mentions a day prior to Bolling’s adoption of the tag.
Next we have the claim that a misspelt version of the tag, #WakeUpAmeirca was the one that was really dominating (with the usual snark about its users being unable to spell and therefore of limited intellect). However, there were only 4313 uses of the misspelt tag on Saturday, with the vast majority of them being retweets. Furthermore, the vast majority of the mentions occurred after the show wrapped for the day (misspelt usages are in blue, correctly spelt mentions are in red):
click to enlarge
In a strange irony, the mocking of the misspelt hashtag may have temporarily got it trending, which caused some folks to assume it was was trending because Cashin’ In fans were misusing it:
Fox News Eric Bolling asked GOP to trend #WakeUpAmerica to mock POTUS. They trended #WakeUpAmeirca The derp is real pic.twitter.com/YC6rJoNg13
— Nerdy Wonka (@NerdyWonka) February 7, 2015
There are two things that are wrong about this assertion. First, a huge portion of the uses of the misspelt hashtag were from critics, not fans. So it’s incorrect to say that Eric Bolling got the wrong hashtag trending. Second, at no time — even during the peak #WakeUpAmeirca — was the wrong hashtag used more than a third of the usage of #WakeUpAmerica. And had you subtracted the critics glee, it would have probably only been a single digit percentage.
There is no doubt that @EricBolling and Cashin’ In broke new ground in social media usage on Saturday and generated an amazing response from his fans on Twitter.
There is no doubt that the surge in use of the #WakeUpAmerica hashtag is completely attributable to the show.
And there is no doubt that the use of the misspelt version of the hashtag amounted to no more than an inconsequential portion of the over all usage, consistent with the amount of typos people normally make in Twitter.
Here’s the raw stats for the day: 2015-02-07-ShowStats.csv
The total mentions for the show are computed from mentions of @EricBolling, #CashinIn, and #WakeUpAmerica, but do not include the #WakeUpAmeirca misspellings. The total number should be even higher when you count those misfires. But I don’t generally include misspellings, so it would be inconsistent to make an exception now.
I was also planning to include a count of mentions of Cashin’ In’s guests in this week’s stats, but I have postponed that until next week given the change in hashtags and the huge increase in week over week counts. I will start to include them in the mix next week as well.
There are many valid criticisms of the opinions voiced on Cashin’ In. But saying that the people who share those opinions are stupid is simply arrogant and not at all a winning strategy. Politics is a strange game: in order to win, you must convert your enemy, not vanquish him.