Clinton to GOP re emails: Checkmate in 3

Did you feel like you got the answers you wanted from Hillary’s press conference? Probably not.  Virtually nobody else seems happy:

  • Republicans say Hillary Clinton’s press conference ‘raised more questions than it answered’ (businessinsider.com)
  • Clinton’s message to voters is, ‘Trust me.’ Will they listen? (washingtonpost.com)
  • Clinton Deleted “Personal” Emails Following Opaque Review Process (buzzfeed.com)
  • Trey Gowdy: ‘Clinton has created more questions than answers’ (politico.com)

And on and on and on.

So are you looking forward to the next round of questions and disclosures? Don’t.  It will not happen.  I know you want to learn some fact or clue that will contradict her statements and prove, well, I’m not sure what, but something bad.  Maybe the servers were hacked by China. Maybe the emails she kept back from State would hurt her election prospects. Maybe she schemed against the interests of America.  You never know what you’ll catch when you go fishing.

But here’s the thing: Hillary Clinton has figured out the absolute minimum she was required to do and the least she has to explain.  She’s fulfilled those obligations and made those explanations. All her pieces are in position now, and it’s checkmate in 3.

Her position is defensible: She supplied the State Department with printed copies of all (so decided by her) relevant emails. She has explained how every aspect of it was logical and legal. She did it for convenience sake. She says she has complied with all relevant laws and rules.  She has indicated that the system was secure and never held classified information.

If you don’t believe it, I feel for you.  I too find the explanation lacking.  Is there a weakness you can exploit? No, there is not.

Here’s the most important line in the press conference: “At the end, I chose not to keep my private personal emails.”  The precise phraseology of “at the end” here means only one thing: someone has taken a sledgehammer to the server — or specifically its disk drives — and littered the fragmentary remains in the Hudson river. All emails, in electronic format, are irretrievably lost.

The paper copies given over are the only thing that’s left of her emails.  That’s why you have to ask State for them.  What she destroyed, she was under no obligation to keep. What she was obligated to keep, she handed over to the custody of the State Department.

So ask whatever else you wish. Try to prove anything. The answers are going to be exactly the same every time. There is nothing else she can say, or provide in response to subpoena because there is nothing left of that the email system. She’s explained it all.  The press will get tired of asking shortly, because they know there’s no way to learn anything else, and that cannot prove there is anything else to learn.

The GOP can try, through its powers in Congress.  But about the third time the Gowdy asks for the same thing, and is told, for the third time, it does not exist or the question can no longer be answered, Hillary will be able to make the case that it’s a baseless witchhunt.  The GOP will have to give up at risk of scoring too many own goals.

Either she was perfectly innocent, or it was the perfect crime, but either way, Hillary’s chess game was perfect.

#WakeUpAmerica dominates Cable News Twitter topics on Sunday, 3/8/15

Cable News Trending Topics for 2015-03-08

Although Fox News’ Cashin’ In was not on the air Sunday, it nevertheless had the top trending hashtag on Sunday, “#WakeUpAmerica”:

Click to enlarge

Click to enlarge

Raw data: 2015-03-08-TagStats.csv and 2015-03-08-WordStats.csv

Top Shows for the day:

Category Mentions Show
Most Mentions During Hour 1159 HBO: Last Week Tonight
Most Mentions During Day 7998 Fox News: Hannity

Overall ratings by network

Network Tweet Count Unique Tweeters Reach Male Female
Fox News 55863 22025 423500520 61 % 39 %
CNN 22556 14926 387042916 55 % 45 %
MSNBC 19337 10040 121877557 56 % 44 %
HBO 3293 2631 9079024 66 % 34 %
Al Jazeera 2057 1474 11601564 50 % 50 %
Comedy Central 1438 1184 9358215 51 % 49 %
HLN 975 749 8911852 46 % 54 %

Most popular hashtags

Hashtag Count
#wakeupamerica 17459
#tcot 11699
#pjnet 6465
#lnyhbt 4783
#selma50 3128
#fns 2323
#iwd2015 2113
#mtp 1823
#nerdland 1810
#teaparty 1690

Tag Cloud across all shows

#2a #7daysofgenius #bencarson #benghazi #blacklivesmatter #c2gthr #cashinin #ccot #cnn #cnnafrica #cnnwomen #disclosure #edchat #ferguson #findingjesus #fns #foxnews #ftn #fullrepeal #fwyrick #godblessamerica #gop #hannity #heforshe #hillary #hillaryemail #icc4israel #impeachobama #inspirewomen #internationalwomensday #iran #irantalks #isis #israel #istandwithbibi #istandwithisrael #iwd2015 #jeffwecan #kellyfile #lastweektonight #lnyhbt #makedclisten #mh370 #molonlabe #morningjoe #msnbc #mtp #nerdland #newday #nightoftoomanystars #noamnesty #nonucleariran #nra #obama #obamacare #obamadestroyingamerica #ocare #p2 #patriots #pjnet #policelivesmatter #radicalislam #realtime #redeye #rednationrising #renewus #rt #savesweetbriar #selma #selma50 #shill #sisterpatriots #standwiththeflag #stophillary2016 #stophillaryin2016 #stopisis #stopislam #tbats #tcot #tdsbreakingnews #teaparty #tgdn #thewonderlist #thisweek #tlot #truth #unions #uniteblue #uniteright #uppers #venezuela #veterans #wakeu #wakeup #wakeupa #wakeupam #wakeupamer #wakeupamerica #wethepeople #ycot

 

Word Cloud across all shows

50 against america american back bad ban black bush clinton clintons co congress country day email emails et ever find flag fox go going good gop graham great hero hillary htt international iran irvine isis israel john just know last law like lindsey love make man many march media much must need netanyahu never new news now obama one people police president private put real really retweet right rights say says see selma sent show state still stop take tells things think time today tonight truth uc us vote want watch watching way white will women women’s work world years

 

John Oliver, Sean Hannity win Cable News Twitter on Sunday, March 8, 2015

Sunday was an unusual day for two reasons.  First, it didn’t have a 2am, owing to the shift to daylight saving time.  Second, there was intermittent live coverage of the 50th anniversary march over the Edmund Pettus bridge in Selma, AL.

I included a set of trackers for MSNBC’s coverage on the off-chance it captured a huge volume of Twitter activity.  It didn’t but, as I mentioned in coverage of Saturday’s results, most people were tweeting about the event itself more than the coverage of the event.

The winners for the day were HBO’s Last Week Tonight (which is a perennial best hour winner on Sundays when it’s on) and Hannity (who often wins best day overall).

Raw data: 2015-03-08-ShowStats.csv

Continue reading

#WakeUpAmerica dominates Cable News Twitter on Saturday, 3/7/15

Cable News Trending Topics for 2015-03-07

With Fox News’ Cashin’ In dominating the day in Cable News Twitter, it’s no surprise that it’s adopted hashtag, #WakeUpAmerica, also was dominant:

Click to enlarge

Click to enlarge

Note that the counts of hashtags is only in the context of Cable News shows and not in general.  For example, the hashtag #selma50 had roughly a quarter of a million mentions on Saturday, far more than the paltry few that also mentioned a show.

Raw data: 2015-03-07-TagStats.csv and 2015-03-07-WordStats.csv

Continue reading

Cashin’ In owns Cable News Twitter on Saturday, March 7, 2015

Saturday saw Fox News’ Cashin’ In haul in an amazing number of mentions, with roughly 7.5K during the 11am hour and over 37K for the day as a whole.  Clearly Cashin’ In’s viewers were deeply engaged in the conversation about the show.  Cashin’ In’s mentions equalled those of the next 9 shows combined!

click to enlarge

click to enlarge

This marks two days in a row that Eric Bolling has dominated Cable News Twitter: Friday, from guest hosting The O’Reilly Factor and Saturday with Cashin’ In.

Ronan Farrow’s “7 days of genius” did respectably well in the noon slot — far better than his normal weekday show typically did.  If MSNBC is sincere in looking for a new way to use him, this kind of programming seems to fit his strengths.

The Melissa Harris-Perry Show pulled in a moderate level of mentions, but the split hosting (with Dorian Warren in New York and MHP herself in Selma) did not seem to catch fire with viewers.

I had expected that the coverage of the 50th anniversary of the Selma march to have done well on Cable News Twitter yesterday, and so I was surprised when it did not.  I suspect that part of that was due to people tweeting about the event itself, rather than the coverage.  I tried to capture the sets of commentators the networks put on the air; CNN fielded an impressive collection, for example.  My coverage may not have been perfect, nonetheless.  I also left the original programs that were preempted by Selma in place, so if you see conflicting shows know that the non-Selma ones probably didn’t run (or fully run).

Raw data: 2015-03-07-ShowStats.csv

Continue reading